Category Archives: General Musings
Earlier today, Presonus introduced Notion 6, its latest version of the Notion music notation program.
Over the past few years, Notion has become a key program for me for a number of reasons:
- iOS version
- Excellent sounds
- Easy audio export (with an embedded DAW)
- Ease of making ukulele charts with embedded fretboards
Remember: I am a Finale-first user, as I have used Finale for over 20 years. I will do much of my raw editing in Finale, and then bring the result (via MusicXML) to Notion (either on my Mac or on my iPad–note: the iOS version works on iPhone, too).
Notion has never balked on my “old” 2008 MacBook, and it has run just about any sort of MIDI connection I throw I at it (I cannot say the same for other programs). If I had to, I could potentially move to Notion as my single notation solution.
“Big” news items for Notion 6 include a new integration with their DAW, Studio One (ver 3), a new visual interface, and the official statement from the PreSonus website:
Notable improvements include: cross-platform handwriting recognition; new layout control and features for professional score output; drag to respace measures and systems; new instruments from Soundiron; new video window controls for faster scoring to picture; the new Notion Scores library, with over 100 great works; updated Music XML support for seamless transfer with other apps; MP3 export; MIDI over ReWire for improved integration with leading digital audio workstations; and unprecedented side-by-side workflow integration with Studio One Artist or Professional on the same computer or between multiple computers on the same network.
I don’t do that much work with DAWs, so whereas I understand the desire to have DAW integration with ReWire, I don’t personally use that feature. ReWire compatibility was also included with the new Finale 25.
The upgrade price to Notion 6 is $50; the purchase price of Notion 6 is $149. Incidentally, if you want the full library of sounds for Notion 6, that is a $299 investment. That may seem like a lot, but that includes ALL of the sounds, where $299 just gets you going with the deluxe libraries of Finale and Sibelius. The purchase of Studio One that works with Notion represents another $100 (minimum) investment.
Should you purchase Notion? If you have an iPad and want to write music, Notion is still the best option, and it works with the Windows/Mac version. The iPad version, while it does not have all the features of the Windows/Mac version, can display anything that the Windows/Mac version can created.
If you want to work with software that is directly created in connection with a DAW, Notion would seem to be a good bet.
If you do any sort of work exporting audio rehearsal files, or want an easy path into notation, Notion is a good purchase. If you are a high-level notation user that needs custom control over every aspect of a notated score, Notion isn’t the program for you.
If you are a MuseScore user, it might be worth the purchase of Notion just to hear your scores from a better quality playback option (admittedly, the iPad version shares those sounds, just with a smaller expressive range with a nod to the storage space on a device). As you know, no software program can compete with the price point of MuseScore.
However, if you are a Finale or Sibelius user, you will need to look at your workflow and decide if another application makes sense for you. The price of the software is certainly enticing, as the purchase price is that same as an upgrade on similar platforms.
Again, Notion has become a major tool in my toolkit, and I certainly feel safe recommending it to others. Like every notation product, it isn’t perfect, and they are always working to squash bugs. But it is a program that I would recommend (just as I do MuseScore and Finale).
Addendum: Apparently Notion for iOS is on sale (thanks, Paul Shimmons) for $8.00! That’s a must-buy. You can also read Paul’s thoughts about Notion 6 on his blog at ipadmusiced.wordpress.com
Back in 2008, I generally stepped away from Windows computers in my home. Our school district was still Windows-based (at the time), and I eventually bought a small Asus T-100 to use when helping teachers (through the blog) with Windows issues.
As I have mentioned recently, I have to retire the Asus as it is a 32-bit computer and too many programs require 64-bit operation these days.
My MacBook dates back to November 2008. I originally bought it to make iPhone apps. I quickly learned that Cocoa, Objective C, and Xcode were things that I would need significant training with to be able to program…and I didn’t have the time as a teacher and parent to learn them (I would still like to, and if I won the lottery, I would want to be an adjunct professor at some college and then a programming student). My MacBook was $1700 with the included Apple Care (I do recommend it on a MacBook), and it was a tough price to pay.
Eight years later, I am still using that machine. I have put in a couple of traditional hard drives over the years, had the DVD drive replaced under warranty, and put in the maximum amount of memory. Until this fall, this MacBook has been supported by Apple OS upgrades, so it is running the latest version of OS X (El Capitan). Sadly, Apple has announced this will be the last version it can run–it is just too old. Early in its life, I dropped the MacBook (while in a bag) and there is a good dent in the corner, and there are lots of other scratches on the machine. But the machine was slow, and it does lack some features that come with newer MacBooks.
All that said, I breathed new life into my MacBook, which will keep me from having to buy a new MacBook (one is coming, but this extends its life further). First, I was sent the WIDI Bud by CME for a review, and now my old MacBook has BLE MIDI (Bluetooth MIDI). Second, I bought a SSD Drive from Amazon on Amazon Prime Day–a 480GB Drive for $92.
Let me be clear about this: If you have a MacBook that uses a traditional drive, an SSD drive will make your machine into a completely different device.
On this older MacBook, replacing a hard drive is relatively easy…with newer MacBooks, it is possible, but requires a little more work to do. You need to have an enclosure for a new drive (take a look at those offered by OWC, or just buy the kit containing drive and enclosure). Then you install the new drive in the enclosure, connect it to the MacBook, and run a cloning program. I recommend Carbon Copy Cloner, which has worked for me every time I have cloned my Hard Drive.
When that program is done, you turn off your computer, make sure you ground yourself (avoid static electricity), disassemble your computer, remove the old drive, install the new drive, put everything back together, and start up the computer.
You will be left with a MacBook that is exactly the same, but incredibly faster.
If you have a MacBook Air, you already have an SSD drive. So do the new MacBooks.
All that said, I wouldn’t hesitate to purchase a used MacBook from 2009 or 2010 (which should still be eligible for Mac OS Sierra) on the cheap, buy a new SSD drive, and walk away with a computer that will last for years.
The real “line in the sand,” however, is 2012. 2012 was the year where MacBooks could communicate via AirDrop with iPads and iPhones, and when BLE was integrated into the device. So for a machine that will last even longer, look for 2012 or newer.
I’m not sure how much longer I will be using this MacBook. It still has cosmetic damage and the battery just doesn’t last (it is on its 3rd battery). But it works with everything that I throw at it, and even programs that used to struggle (e.g. Finale 2014.5), it can run those programs without an issue thanks to a speedy SSD drive.
Of course, if you are terrible with electronics and struggle to use a screwdriver or to run a program on a computer–don’t try to replace your hard drive. Find someone else that can do it with you or for you.
But if you are a MacBook user whose computer is old and slow…putting in a new drive is a great way to breathe new life into an old purchase.
If you are a Windows user, you’ll need to check forums to see what options exist for your machine.
One other thought: make sure that your SSD drive is TRIM capable, and after your new drive is installed, make sure to turn on TRIM support. TRIM allows the Mac OS to properly manage the new SSD drive to make sure that data is stored and erased properly for the maximum life of the drive.
I have written a little about my experiences in incorporating ukulele into the choir curriculum at my middle school. As this school year approaches, I am changing the definition of choir into a program with three areas of emphasis:
- Sight Reading (with Dale Duncan’s S-Cubed program)
What we did with the ukulele last year was a tremendous start, and it is time to create this new hybrid approach. I believe that students that come out of my program will be able to sight read better, have better developed ears, have a better understanding of music (chord progressions), and have the ability to succeed at the high school level in “real choir.” My students will be missing the experience of singing in three and four part choirs through 8th grade–but they will have the ability to accompany their own singing on an instrument than pretty much any person can purchase. Those students that don’t continue in high school choir (70-75%) will have a skill that they can use the rest of their lives, or a skill that transfers somewhat easily to guitar. This is a win-win and a no-brainer.
Over the last weeks, I have been arranging music for voice (unison or two part) and ukulele–all of it intended for a holiday concert. I will post some of these arrangements–particularly those that are in the Public Domain. Choosing repertoire is a little tricky as sacred music is “out” for choir in my school. Even so, I have come up with thirty-two songs that refer to Christmas (or Hanukkah) in terms of a secular season versus a religious holiday. Sacred music, in our school, needs to be in extra-curricular ensembles (where people choose to be and are not required to be), or just out of school in general. I am thinking of offering an extra-curricular ukulele choral ensemble that will play sacred holiday music (e.g. “Silent Night”) at local retirement homes (and so on). And to those of you who are wondering–this is NOT worth the fight. Our high schools can still pursue sacred music, and if my willingness to avoid it makes it possible for them to pursue it–that is worth the cost. And you know what? There is a LOT of music out there, even “secular” holiday music. Some of that music is surprisingly difficult to play/sing/arrange!
All that said, ukulele is out of the focus and scope of this blog, which is focused on technology in music education. While this is “my” blog, it does have a theme. Technology does play a part in all of my teaching (and all three areas of emphasis noted above), but the ukulele content needs another location–and as far as I know, no other school or teacher in the country is creating a hybrid choir/ukulele program.
As a result of all this, I have created a new blog for that ukulele content. If ukulele content interests you, check it out: https://ukestuff.wordpress.com. There are already a number of posts on the blog (I wanted something there before making things public).
And if you are a teacher that uses ukulele and would like to write something but not commit to a regular blog, let me know. I would be happy to include a post from a guest.
I received an e-mail from a reader who has a WIDI BUD and they wanted to bring up some specific issues with the device, and I thought it would be good to share their observations with you, as well as a few of my own after my own extended testing today.
In my last post about the XKey Air and the WIDI BUD, I talked about how the WIDI BUD can link to other BLE MIDI devices. This is not always true. I was able to connect Zivix products to a WIDI BUD on Mac, Chromebook, and Windows with no problems. I did not try the Quicco Sound mi.1 MIDI to BLE MIDI dongle that I have in my home, and I can verify that the mi.1 does not connect to the WIDI BUD at this time. Likewise, the reader mentioned that the Yamaha MD-BT01 and the Yamaha UD-BT01 do not connect to the WIDI BUD. (Update 8/3/2016) Yamaha was gracious enough to send me the UD-BT01, and I was able to connect it to the WIDI Bud on both my old Mac (without BLE MIDI) and my Chromebook. So far, I am not able to get the WIDI Bud to work with my old Asus T-100 Transformer Windows computer.
I don’t know why this is the case–but if you have the mi.1, the WIDI BUD will not work for you at this time. I do not know if a future firmware update can solve the problem, but I thought it was worth mentioning.
The other item that the reader wanted to bring to your attention is that there are some apps that modify the functionality of the WIDI BUD available for download directly off of CME’s website. They also wanted to highlight that documentation for the WIDI BUD and its accompanying software leaves much to be desired.
I am not troubled by this issue at all..BLE MIDI is still a relatively new feature, and I am hoping future firmware updates can solve these problems.
Granted, SmartScore lite was never the best option, but they were going to greatly increase its functionality.
From the Sibelius blog: http://www.sibeliusblog.com/opinion/makemusic-pulls-pdf-importing-and-scanning-from-finale/
My response: ARRRRGGGHHH!
Instead of making an easier path to legally obtain copyright at prices that reflect school budgets and allows for best practice use of technology, this potentially leads to a more restrictive future with higher prices and more difficultly in using technology.
What a sad day.
MakeMusic will incorporate scanning into SmartMusic, which will be of value to music educators (I’m not sure how you would edit scanning errors), but to those that use Finale, another path of music OCR will be needed.
*8:20pm edited to reflect that scanning will be a part of SmartMusic.